Welcome to Pizza Place & Trattoria II
Nestled on 35 Main St in Brewster, NY, Pizza Place & Trattoria II is a culinary gem that celebrates the essence of NY-style pizza. Renowned for its large slices boasting a perfect cheese-to-sauce ratio, the pizzas are complemented by a delightful crunch and a tender, non-oily crust. Diners rave about the garlic knots and unique offerings like Bronx-style pizza, gyros, and homemade Nutella pies. The welcoming atmosphere, coupled with attentive service from dedicated staff and the owner, makes every visit special. With a commitment to quality and flavor, this trattoria is a must-visit for pizza enthusiasts and families alike.
Pizza Place & Trattoria II: Reviews & Ratings
One of the best NY style pizza I’ve had at a reasonable price too. The slices were large with a good cheese to sauce ratio. Sauce was a bit acidic, but not overwhelming. The dough was soft and held its form well, crust was crunchy on the outside and soft within. It wasn’t oily either. Their garlic knots were a bit small, but you get 6. They were really soft and not too garlicky. I’d get marinara sauce on the side.
Bronx Style pizza, with an upscale touch. Gyros, chicken parm , cheeseburgers and much more! Garlic knots are a must, ask for them to add pizza sauce and cheese on top! Plenty of parking but remember to grab a quarter! Right next to the train station as well!
The pizza was phenomenal. And huge slices for the price. Also took home a Nutella pie for the kids. If you’re in Brewster. Give them a try you wo t be disappointed.
The food is always delicious. Whenever I order from the place I get so excited. The wings are delicious surprise or delicious although the mozzarella sticks the cheese is a little dry. Everything else is really good. Most of the time they’re on, but the longest they’ve been late is like 20 minutes. I recommend going here.
I’m so blessed to have Pizza Place & Trattoria ll in my neighborhood. I’ve visited so many pizza spots around the country and nothing comes even close to this place. The food, service and atmosphere make this place an absolute gem. Shoutout to everyone working here including the owner, he’s often seen working along his crew and making deliveries! Besides pizza, Spinach Rolls are a must have! Clean customer bathroom and tables.
Best two slices I ever had! I often come and have two slices and just the way I like, I recommend this place % Warm atmosphere and calm environment clean and relaxed, come and enjoy their famous slices you won't regret it! May this place be blessed and abundant you deserve it. Peace be with you!
THESE PEOPLE ARE AMAZING! I called to get a delivery to my best friend who just got engaged. I asked if they could do a heart shape in pepperoni. Without hesitation they agreed- even though he said they have never done it before. It turned out GREAT! And she was so happy! THANK YOU!
This is my go to place everytime I come to brewster. Besides Carvel. Love the chicken francese great place great food great people!100%recommended
Location
-
35 Main St, Brewster, NY 10509, United States Hotline: +1 845-279-4114
Welcome to Pizza Place & Trattoria II, nestled at 35 Main St, Brewster, NY. This local gem is more than just a pizzeria—it's an experience. With the aroma of fresh-baked pizza wafting through the air, your taste buds are in for a treat. This eatery offers an exciting blend of Bronx-style pizza coupled with an upscale twist on classic American fare, making it a perfect spot for both the family and date nights.
The rave reviews from patrons like Enmanuel Arias and Ahmet Ulutas highlight the irresistible appeal of their dishes. The New York-style pizza is particularly noteworthy; described as having an ideal balance of cheese and sauce, its crunchy exterior gives way to a soft, flavorful interior. Customers rave about the generous portion sizes, ensuring that you leave feeling satisfied without breaking the bank. Though some noted the marinara's slight acidity, it adds character rather than detracts from the pizza's overall flavor profile.
But the pizza isn't the only star here. The garlic knots have become a must-try, with many recommending them topped with pizza sauce and cheese for an extra kick. While they might be a tad smaller than expected, they deliver on flavor and are perfectly soft, providing a delightful prelude to your main meal.
For those looking for variety, Pizza Place & Trattoria II has plenty to offer. From mouthwatering gyros to the ever-popular chicken parmesan and even cheeseburgers, their diversity makes it an ideal dining destination for any occasion. Customers like Geovanny emphasize the fantastic service, often seeing the owner involved in daily operations, which adds a personal touch that makes this establishment feel like home.
And don’t overlook the delicious dessert options! The Nutella pie has garnered attention as a delightful treat to share with family after a meal. In addition to all of this, the food is consistently praised for its quality and taste, making Pizza Place & Trattoria II an essential stop for pizza aficionados and families alike.
With convenient parking adjacent to the train station, visiting this establishment is a seamless experience. Whether you're a local or just passing through Brewster, be sure to swing by and indulge in what many are calling the crème de la crème of pizzerias.
In closing, Pizza Place & Trattoria II stands out not just for its exceptional food quality but also for the community atmosphere it fosters. No wonder so many patrons leave with smiles on their faces and a longing to return!